Then he showeth them their work, and their transgressions that they have exceeded.
9. that they have exceeded ] Or, have dealt proudly, ch. Job 33:17.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
9 10. The meaning of afflictions they are a divine warning and stimulus to rouse men out of a sinful lethargy and bring their sin to their remembrance.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
Then he showeth them their work – What their lives have been. This he does either by a messenger sent to them Job 33:23, or by their own reflections Job 33:27, or by the influences of his Spirit leading them to a proper review of their lives. The object of their affliction, Elihu says, is to bring them to see what their conduct has been, and to reform what has been amiss. It should not be interpreted either as proof that the afflicted are eminently wicked, as the friends of Job maintained, or as furnishing an occasion for severe reflections on the divine government, such as Job had indulged in. It is all consistent with an equitable and kind administration; with the belief that the afflicted have true piety – though they have wandered and erred; and with the conviction that God is dealing with them in mercy, and not in the severity of wrath. They need only recal the errors of their lives; humble themselves, and exercise true repentance, and they would find afflictions to be among even their richest blessings.
Transgressions that they have exceeded – Or, rather, he shows them their transgressions that they have been very great; that they have made themselves great, mighty, strong – yitgabaru. The idea is, that their transgressions had been allowed to accumulate, or to become strong, until it was necessary to interpose in this manner, and check them by severe affliction. All this was consistent, however, with the belief that the sufferer was truly pious and might find favor if he would repent.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
Job 36:9
Then He sheweth them their work, and their transgression that they have exceeded.
Showing up our transgressions
I. General remarks on the text.
1. Sin is properly attributable to man. It is their work. If God suffers moral evil to exist, He is not the author of it. Satan may tempt, but cannot constrain to the commission of sin. The whole guilt of it lies upon the offender. It first exists as simple apprehension, is then approved, and, being conceived in the heart, it brings forth actual transgression, until it is finished in death.
2. It is the prerogative of God effectually to convince men of sin; or, to show unto them their work. No man ever saw his sinfulness in a proper light until it was thus discovered to him.
3. The Lord frequently imparts this knowledge in a season of affliction: then it shows unto men their work. It was in deep adversity that Job was made to possess the iniquities of his youth, to recollect what had been long forgotten, and to feel the burden of his guilt.
4. The knowledge of our sinfulness is necessary to true repentance, and to our believing in Christ for eternal life. Sorrow for sin, confessing and forsaking it, will be the immediate effect. An irreconcilable hatred to sin, and an earnest desire to have it mortified and subdued, will be the necessary consequence of a true conviction of its evil nature.
II. In what respects the Lord may be said to show unto men their transgressions.
1. He makes known to them the fact that they are sinners, and that their transgressions are their own.
2. The Lord convinces them not only of the fact, but also of the evil of sin, and causes them to repent of that, as well as of its consequences.
3. When persons are truly convinced Of sin, the Lord not only shows them their work end their transgression, but also that they have exceeded. They are made to see that they have sinned with a high hand. God employs various means, and accompanies them with various effects. God often renews the discovery of sin in our later experience. (B. Beddom,, M. A.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Verse 9. He showeth them their work] He shows them the exceeding sinfulness of sin.
That they have exceeded.] yithgabbaru, “that they have strengthened themselves,” and did not trust in the living God; and therefore they would not help themselves when trouble came.
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
Their work, i.e. their evil works, as the next clause explains and limits it. By these afflictions he brings them to a sight of their sins and to repentance, which is the way and means of their recovery.
That they have exceeded; that they have greatly sinned by abusing their power and prosperity; which even good men are too prone to do.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
9. worktransgression.
that . . . exceeded“Inthat they behaved themselves mightily” (literally, “great”);that is, presumptuously, or, at least, self-confidently.
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
Then he showeth them their work,…. Either what they ought to do, so the Tigurine version; and which they have not done, their sins of omission; when they have been negligent either of the duty of prayer in private and public, or of attendance on the ordinances of the house of God; then he sends an affliction, and by it, as in a glass, presents to their view the omissions they have been guilty of: or else the work which they have done, and should not have done, their sins of commission: sin is a work at which some toil and labour, and weary themselves to commit; it is a work of the flesh; and so it is in good men; it is a man’s own work, and which he can work of himself; to have a will, and to do good works, is owing to God working in his people, and it is through him strengthening them they do them; but sin fill works are their own act and deed, though tempted to them by others, and which they are able to do of their own freewill and power. Now God, in the glass of affliction, holds forth to view the sinful actions of good men, and brings them to their remembrance which they had forgotten; as the cases of Joseph’s brethren, David, and others, prove: the Lord shows them that they have done such actions, and shows them the evil of them, how exceeding sinful they are; and humbles them under a sense of them, and brings them to repentance for them, and the acknowledgment of them; which sense is confirmed by the next clause, which explains what this their work is,
and their transgressions that they have exceeded. Sin is a transgression of the law, 1Jo 3:4; every sin, greater or lesser, is, and even righteous persons are guilty of many; for there is not a just man that sinneth not; and these exceed the bounds set by the righteous law of God, and many of them are sadly aggravated by the light and knowledge, grace and mercy, such have been favoured with; and some of them, they are suffered to fall into, are exceeding great and exceeding sinful; such as those of David, Peter, and others; all which they are made to see, bewail, and weep over, when God by afflictions brings them to a sense of them. Or “when” or “because they have prevailed” m; or begin to prevail: as soon as ever indwelling sin begins to be prevalent, the Lord is pleased to take measures to nip it in the bud, by sending a sharp and severe affliction; or when it has prevailed greatly, as sometimes it does, so that good is hindered from being done, and much evil is committed, then the soul is so much under the power of it, as to be carried captive with it; see Ro 7:23. Or “because they are become proud”, or “behaved themselves proudly” n; and therefore he afflicts them to humble them, and drive pride from them.
m “quum invalescunt”, Mercerus; “quum invaluerunt”, Munster, Piscator; so Drusius, Panginus, Bolducius. n “Quia superbierunt”, Tigurine version; so Cocceius, Michaelis, Schultens.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
(9) Then he sheweth them their work.The true nature of their conduct and their transgressions, that they have behaved themselves proudly. This is Elihus special doctrine, that Gods chastisements are by way of discipline, to reform the future rather than to chastise the past.
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
9. That they have exceeded The Authorized Version is ambiguous; the literal reading is, “They show themselves strong.” In other words, God declares to them that they act proudly, (against him;) one of the dangers of extreme prosperity.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Job 36:9. That they have exceeded How they have set him at defiance. Heath.
Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke
Job 36:9 Then he sheweth them their work, and their transgressions that they have exceeded.
Ver. 9. Then he showeth them their work ] By these sharp waters he cleareth up their eyesight, and gives them to see their sin, the mother of their misery. Vexatio dat intellectum, Smart makes wit. Manasseh, for instance, and the prodigal, and King Croesus, with his Nocumenta documenta, and Tullus Hostilius, with his excess of devotion, when once he had paid for his learning (Herodot. lib. 1. Liv. decad. 1, l. 5).
And their transgressions that they have exceeded
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
transgressions. Hebrew. pasha’. App-44.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
he: Job 10:2, Deu 4:21, Deu 4:22, 2Ch 33:11-13, Psa 94:12, Psa 119:67, Psa 119:71, Lam 3:39, Lam 3:40, Luk 15:17-19, 1Co 11:32
their: Psa 5:10, Isa 59:12, Eze 18:28-31, Rom 5:20, 1Ti 1:15
Reciprocal: Gen 42:21 – they said Job 13:23 – make me Psa 107:10 – bound
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
36:9 Then he sheweth them their {f} work, and their transgressions that they have exceeded.
(f) He will move their hearts to feel their sins that they may come to him by repentance as he did Manasseh.